jump to navigation

Mulan – Review May 7, 2009

Posted by Cello in Domestic Film Reviews.


Mulan is Disney’s 36th animated movie. In my opinion it is their BEST family film. My concept of a “family film” is a movie that can be enjoyed by viewers of all ages: undiscriminating young children, teenagers with short attention spans, and adults with somewhat more refined standards.  Based upon Chinese folklore, the film follows the escapades of a young girl called Fa Mulan. Problems arise when her aged father is summoned to join the war against invading Huns. In an act of filial devotion (and obligation) Mulan secretly takes his place in the army by disguising herself as a man; knowing full well that such an act is punishable by death under military law.

All the familiar ingredients of Disney animated movies are mixed in: slapstick comedy, adventure, scary parts, wacky sidekicks (both animal and human), a little romance, lessons learned, and some show tunes thrown in. Mulan resists being read as simply a banal piece of Disney fluff. The film offers an opportunity to see the unobvious made more obvious; that is the constructedness of gendered identity and sexuality, and the instability of such constructions. Mulan manages to avoid many of the stereotypical pitfalls that normally plague Western takes on aspects of Asian culture.


However, that territory does come with its flaws. And maybe I’m making too much of it, but I love Asian cinema, and I really wanted Mulan to at least try to respect the culture and history of the people it portrayed.  And every time one of the Oriental characters burst into a bombastic Western ballad, the illusion was just that much more destroyed. Still, Mulan offers viewers a glimpse into another culture that many children’s movies don’t. Many aspects of Chinese culture are incorporated, such as reverence to one’s ancestors, the significance of dragons, and the importance of honor.

Unsurprisingly, the animation is top-notch. The film has a unique look for an animated motion picture, using many more unusual camera angles than have previously been attempted in this kind of effort. Although this type of animation is a dying art in the motion picture business, it still has a great look to it. Mulan doesn’t rely upon occasional double entendres to earn its acceptance with adults. Some of the dialogue is specifically aimed at an older audience. There’s not so much that children will become confused or bored, but there’s enough for Mom and Dad not to feel like they’re being ignored or talked down to.  A great overall flick and a Disney classic worth putting into your library.



1. ironanno - May 7, 2009

Great writeup of the movie. Any movie with what’s basicly a three minute training montage get’s my points.:) Without kidding I agree in most parts with what you had to say.

My main criticism on the movie concerns the end part of the film that didn’t work so well in my opinion. The most epic part of the movie is when the hun’s assemble on top of the mountain in that gigantic line. The small Chinese troop supposed to fight against them looks ridiculous in comparison. Of course Disney couldn’t have an epic battle so they dealt with that with Mulan taking care of the entire troop of Huns with the rocket. After that the strongest Huns rise from the snow. There’s so few of them that as an adult viewer you know there’s not really any way that they could take China anymore.

But, as you say, it is a children’s movie. It just that that epic scene with the Huns was the most spectacular part of the movie and it wasn’t as exciting after that.

2. leetgamer - May 7, 2009

Oh god, Mulan… I loved that cartoon. I love mushu too. You should review Mulan 2 btw ! Keep up the good work 😀

3. ekaria27 - May 8, 2009

Havent got time to watch this. will do 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: